Building online direct sales, part one of three
An agent can take a booking in three steps. Most operator websites I look at take nine or more, and two of those steps happen on a different domain.
That gap is the whole problem. It is not a marketing problem. It is a plumbing problem, and you can fix it this month.
The number that should worry you
Four in ten operators across Australia and New Zealand named growing direct bookings as their leading priority for 2026. That figure comes from the Arival State of Experiences in ANZ report, released in May.
In the same report, agents went from 24% of bookings to 31%. Operator websites went the other way, from 32% down to 28%.
So the intention is pointing one direction and the bookings are moving the other. That does not happen because operators are lazy. It happens because wanting direct business is free and building the path to it is not.
Here is the other number. The Baymard Institute puts average cart abandonment across online retail at just over 70%. Roughly three in ten people who start a checkout actually finish it. Your booking engine is not exempt from that. Nobody sends you a report on the seven people who got to the payment screen last Tuesday and walked away.
Why your booking path is worse than theirs
Agents have teams of people whose entire job is checkout. They test the button colour. They test where the price sits. They test how many taps it takes on a phone in poor reception.
You have a website that a designer built to look good, a booking engine that was bolted on afterwards, and a Tuesday afternoon between staff rosters and a supplier invoice.
That is the structural reason. It is not a failure of effort on your part. You are competing on conversion against businesses that treat conversion as their product.
There is a second reason, and it is more uncomfortable. Most operators have never bought their own tour. You know what your booking page says because you wrote it. You have never sat there as a stranger with a credit card and a bit of doubt.
Direct Bookings Dive, OTAs Rise
What the guest is actually deciding
The Changing Traveller Report from SiteMinder surveyed 12,000 travellers across 14 countries, including Australia. Australian travellers who book direct said they do it for three reasons. Greater control at 68%, better service at 67%, and competitive pricing at 66%.
Read that again, because it matters. Price came third.
People are not booking direct to save eight dollars. They are booking direct because they want to talk to a human if the weather turns, and they want to know they can change the date. Your website has to say that out loud.
Most do not. Most say "Book Now" and hope.
What it looks like when it is fixed
The total price is visible before anyone enters a name. No surprise fees at step four. Hidden costs are the single most reliable way to lose a booking that was already yours.
The whole thing works on a phone in one hand. Test it standing up, outside, in sunlight.
The questions your team answers on the phone all day are answered in text on the page. How long is the walk. Is there parking. Can my mother do it with a knee replacement. If somebody has to ring you to find out, most of them will not ring. They will book the thing that already told them.
Confirmation is instant and it comes from a person, not from "no-reply@".
And there is a clear reason to book with you rather than through an agent. Not a discount. A reason. Direct guests get the earlier departure time. Direct guests can move their date once for free. Direct guests get the guide who has been there 15 years.
What this looked like for me
When I took over Aquaduck, 4% of our bookings came direct. By the time I finished, it was 47%.
That did not come from a website rebuild. It came from working the same plan every single month, and from knowing our numbers well enough to see what was actually happening.
We tracked maximum capacity for every day and every tour across the year. We catalogued every market discount. We reviewed the channel mix against direct sales monthly, not annually.
Over the same period we moved the ticket price from $36 to $50. The previous owners told me the ceiling was $40. It was not. Net profit per passenger went from one dollar to three.
I have to say, none of that was clever. It was just done consistently, and most operators never get to consistently.
The 30 minutes that will annoy you
Do this today, before you read part two.
Open your website on your phone. Not your laptop. Pretend you have never heard of your business.
Book your own tour, all the way to the payment screen, and pay for it. Use a real card. You can refund yourself afterwards.
While you do it, write down four things. How many screens it took. How long it took, in minutes and seconds. The exact moment you had to guess at something. And whether the total price you paid matched the price you first saw.
Then hand your phone to someone over 60 who has never used your website, and watch them try. Say nothing while they do it. That silence will be the most useful ten minutes of your year.
If your process takes more than four screens, or if the price changed on the way through, you do not have a marketing problem. You have a leak, and you are paying agents 20% to 30% commission to fill the bucket you are leaking out of.
Part two covers the guests you have already paid for once, and why most operators never speak to them again.
Want to see where your direct channel is strong and where the commission is quietly taking your margin? Complete the Tourism Business Health Check at exceptionalexperiences.com.au/tourism-business-health-check
Sources
Arival, Global Operator Landscape 4th Edition: The State of Experiences in Australia and New Zealand, May 2026. Baymard Institute cart abandonment benchmark, 2026. SiteMinder, Changing Traveller Report 2026.
Sarah Colgate | 0491 729 043 | exceptionalexperiences.com.au